I find that I'm not interested spending my limited time in analyzing a vid that I find incoherent, but I agree with you that it's a failure, not because I don't agree with it, but because it isn't clear enough about what it's saying for me to tell what I'm supposed to be agreeing or disagreeing with. I'm a little WTF? at the people I see calling it brilliant -- they definitely are seeing something that I don't; I think they are seeing something that isn't (intentionally) there.

And I thought you might find this amusing: Some people decided, after some discussion, that they had figured the vid out: It was a fuck you to Vividcon, in that the vid didn't mean anything/was purposefully muddled.